How to Run Smarter, More Effective 1:1s

Introduction: The Challenge of Effective 1:1s in Today's Work Environment

The performance review process is a critical component of employee management and development. Despite their importance, many organizations struggle to make these interactions impactful. A significant number of team members view performance reviews as unproductive, with a mere 14% feeling inspired to improve. This calls for a transformative approach, integrating Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) to address the strengths and weaknesses in the current performance review process.

Why Rethinking 1:1s is Crucial

1:1s are essential for providing constructive feedback and performance feedback, yet they often fail to accurately reflect an employee's contribution. In a typical scenario, performance review examples show that performance ratings do not always align with the actual employee's performance. This misalignment can lead to ineffective performance appraisals and generic performance review templates and phrases that do not address specific aspects of an employee's work performance. An effective performance review should include a performance improvement plan and a comprehensive performance evaluation that truly assesses performance and on the job behaviors.

The Solution: Integrating ONA into 1:1s

How ONA Works in 1:1s

1. Identifying Key Players and Hidden Talents: ONA can reveal individuals whose past performance and ability to improve skills have been overlooked. This is crucial for a thorough review process that recognizes not just organizational skills but also when an employee fails to meet expectations or when an employee's work needs improvement.
2. Understanding Relationships and Influence: Questions in ONA can uncover the informal networks within a team, providing insights beyond what is typically discussed in performance reviews.
3. Tailoring Development Plans: Insights from ONA can inform development plans that address specific areas, such as customer service, communication skills, problem solving, and leadership qualities.
4. Reducing Bias: ONA provides objective data, reducing the subjective judgments that can influence performance ratings.

Implementing ONA in Your 1:1s

1. Start with the Right Questions: Incorporate ONA questions into your 1:1s to get a better understanding of day to day work and how an employee exceeds expectations or contributes to the business strategy.
2. Use Technology Wisely: Utilize ONA tools to analyze data, which can be more effective than traditional performance review templates.
3. Train Managers: Ensure managers understand how to use ONA insights in conjunction with annual reviews and goal setting to enhance the well-being of employees.
4. Integrate with Performance Reviews: Combine ONA insights with performance review phrases and performance feedback to create a more effective performance review process.

The Benefits of ONA-Enhanced 1:1s

1. More Accurate Performance Assessments: ONA helps in accurately assessing an employee's accomplishments and individual performance.
2. Increased Employee Engagement and Retention: Recognizing key contributors can lead to higher job satisfaction and lower turnover rates.
3. Data-Driven Decision Making: ONA provides objective data for decisions about promotions, team restructuring, and talent development.
4. Enhanced Team Dynamics: Understanding informal networks can help in managing team dynamics and building strong relationships.

Conclusion: Embracing a New Era of 1:1s

Integrating Organizational Network Analysis into 1:1 meetings can revolutionize how organizations assess, develop, and engage their employees. This approach aligns more closely with the realities of modern, networked work environments and enhances the effectiveness of these crucial interactions.

Further Reading

For more insights on fixing performance reviews, check out SHRM’s article: Fixing Performance Reviews for Good.

‍